opinion piece posted by

The Gadget Manifesto – or 25 reasons why we’re getting tired of trashy Far East manufacturing…


Try this test. Take a 10 minute look around your home or office and see how many home, computer or personal technology items you own that are broken in some way. Done it….?

Wanna see our list?

* Microsoft Trackball Explorer. Cut out after around a year. Just stopped registering. Status: Unusable
* Kensington Expert Mouse Pro. Cut out after around a year. Stopped moving in one direction. Status: Unusable
* Nextlink BlueSpoon Headset (x2). Neither would work at all out of the box. Status: Completely useless
* Dualphone (original). LCD screen degraded until several numbers unreadable. Status: Painful to use.
* Casio Exilim S3 digital camera. Flash failed after 10 months use. Status: Repaired via workshop
* Nokia 3230. Power button faulty and speaker audio almost non-existent. Status: Working with faults.
* Siemens SX1. Frequent crashes from operating system. Status: Working with faults.
* Linksys WIP320 Skype Phone. Power button faulty from new. Status: Working with faults.
* Dualphone 3088. Firmware fails to update. Status: Working with faults.
* Sony Cybershot T9 Digital Camera. Fails to hold settings or battery life. Status: Almost unusable.
* Brother MFC620N inkjet. Machine fails to register full ink cartridges. Status: Unusable.
* Kensington Notebook Expansion Dock. Fails to work with proper screen resolutions. Status: Working with faults.
* Harmony 525 Remote Control. Button presses fail to work with set top box. Status: Working with faults.
* VeseNet Powerline Camera. Fails to register on Powerline network. Status: Unusable.
* Logitech VX Revolution. Left mouse button intermittently fails to register. Status: Painful to use.
* Philips 7FF1 Digital Photo Frame. Failed to hold settings from new. Status: Working with faults.
* WinTV HVR USB Television. Failed to receive channels from new. Status: Unusable.
* HomePlug 1.0 Network Module. Failed to work out of the box. Status: Swapped out for new.
* Plantronics Voyager 510 Headset (x2). Audio out stopped working after several weeks of use. Status. Both unusable.
* Toshiba Tecra 9000 (x2). USB port failure, sound card failure, WiFi module failure. Status: Both working with faults.
* Unbranded 7 Port USB Hub. Failed to handle rated number of attached peripherals from new. Status: Unusable.
* Laks USB Watch. USB memory failed after several months of use. Status: Unusable.
* Several USB Memory Drives. Failed to work after a few months. Status: Unusable.
* Electrolux Cyclone Power Vacuum Cleaner. Screams like a jet engine after a few months. Status: Barely usable.
* HTC Touch Mobile Phone. Screen started to degrade within days of new. Both stylii broken. Status: Working with faults.

The twenty five examples above were identified within 15 minutes, so this is not an exhaustive list at all. And notice that several of the products are ones we have recommended or labeled as ‘cool’ in our short term tests, which shows just how fallible the short term gadget review process is. And things are getting worse. The last straw was the HTC Touch, a product barely 3 months old and priced at around £300 or so, which has started falling apart faster than you can say ‘Beijing Summer’.


So behold, our personal Gadget Manifesto as directed towards the tech manufacturers of this world.

1) We’re tired of stuff which lasts only as long as the warranty period before crashing out on us right in the middle of our most important tasks. Make the stuff last longer, and hire a quality control guy OK? Heck, hire two.

2) We’re tired of this constant and relentless instant obsolescence. Why don’t you release a great product at launch, instead of holding back on features that cost pennies in order to give yourself a long term skim pricing roadmap?

3) We’re weary of hearing just how outdated our current model is, when compared with the new version which you’re announcing 6 months early, 3 months after this one hit the stores. Why not spend more time testing your stuff and less working on that snazzy PR campaign?

4) We’re fed up with product spam. It may make it easy for you to segment your pricing and markets by delivering 15 new gadgets in a range, but it confuses the heck out of us, and means we have to spend five times as long researching the Internet to avoid the rip-off models.

5) We’re sick of having to dump unusable devices into drawers because we can’t find anyone to repair them, or if they do, they charge slightly less than the national debt of Zimbabwe for the privilege. And take 8 months to get it back to us. Maybe you can design back into your products the easy repairability you removed in your drive to maximise those profit margins? And hire some more people in your organisation who know how to fix your products and can help guide the repair agencies. Hey, why not go the whole hog and write a readily accessible repair manual for your product range?

6) If the above means that you have to slow up the product release cycle, then hey, go for it (see 2). You may make less profit, but maybe you’ll build up more brand loyalty in the long run as people fall in love with your product quality and customer care focus.

7) We’re bored with hearing how you’re giving us, as consumers, what we demand. We’re not demanding it, you’re creating it and then selling it to us as an upgrade, a revolutionary new blah or whatever. Just get real and admit that your roadmap is based solely on maximizing profit. There’s no shame in that.

Finally, we’re sick and tired of watching top quality, much loved consumer technology brands being forced to sink down into the cheap trashy manufacturing cesspit by the rest of you know-nothing, me-too, clone it cheap, conveyer belt junk jockeys. We don’t mind so much if you no-names produce trash, at those prices at least we know what to expect. But when our favourite stars start having to compete with you on price or go out of business, no one wins. We lose the trust in a name that may have existed for 100s of years, they lose a loyal customer base and the world slips lower into the poisonous landfill of throwaway consumerism. It’s not a pretty future.


  • XM Satellite Radio Delphi I’m not sure if their other models are as bad as this one, but when it finally died I simply dumped the service. It started out broken, and became more so over the year I had it.

    1. Programmable recording – never worked.

    2. Headphone connection – fickle after 2 months, had to apply pressure to plug in order to make a connection.

    3. Battery recharging – fickle after 6 months, sometimes worked, sometimes didn’t. Never knew when power would suddenly die.

    4. Connection to car caddy – died after 8 months. Plug simply wouldn’t connect reliably.

    5. Reception – suddenly died after 10 months. Normally it receives a terrestrial signal when not connected to a satellite antenna. Except when it decides not to.

    Wish the hardware were better, the content was okay. Perhaps their merger with Sirius will result in better equipment. It couldn’t get much worse.

  • Joel at BoingBoing has got a good list of his broken stuff too, Nate. Seems we’re not alone. :-)

  • Hey Red, I’m assuming that all the gadgets you’ve referred to up there have been ones you’ve bought and not “pre-release” testers that the manufacturers have given you to play with. Early release stuff is bound to be problematic.

    Looking around my area I’m having trouble finding broken stuff and I don’t really know why.

    We have a film-fed Nikon 601 SLR from 1993 that’s still going well but is barely used these days.

    A Canon Ixus 500 that’s almost 4 years old, it’s been skiing, dropped and had trips to the beach. It’s rocking on.

    Nikon D80. Rock solid and 1 year old.

    Several USB memory sticks including U3 4Gb one. No probs, up to 2 years old.

    My Nokia N73 is 10 months old and apart from the occasional reboot runs like a clock. It did come with a broken charger though and despite the Nokia Shop woman telling me I’d be back in a week with a broken phone it’s been going great. My last 3 Nokias are still in a drawer and working fine as are all their chargers. Wired headsets? They last about a month.

    iRiver H10 5Gb. It’s 3 years old and the battery is half dead and it’s spent it’s life at the bottom of a bag, but it’s still hanging in there and sounds great.

    I did have a Dell Latitude D820 from work for a while. It was a complete dog until IT reinstalled XP. My current Dell M90 is fine but again was reinstalled clean with XP.

    A Gateway P3 866 MHz PC from 1999 running Ubuntu. No problems with that and it’s been upgraded up the wazoo.

    We have a Compaq Pentium Mobile 1.4GHz notebook that’s 3 years old and going great, but again has almost no battery life. No screen degradation or screen cable probs. 1 slightly dodgy USB port.

    My father has had 3 broken Toshiba Tecras over the last 5 years. All with hard drive controller failures, all out of warranty and all fatal.

    We have a Netgear Cable Router (2 years old) and ADSL Modem (3 months) both going strong.

    Windows wireless desktop (mouse + kb) doing ok with occasional disconnects.

    Blueant X9 Bluetooth headphone. Barely works on A2DP due to interference, but I suspect that’s my laptop’s fault. Everything else works great battery life is superb.

    Blueant X3 Bluetooth Headset. Ear hook is loose, but electrically great, 2 years old and quite abused.

    I have a box of optical and trackball computer mice, wired and unwired. Some 7 years old. All working mainly Logitech and M$.

    Two Dell Monitors, a 2407 (4 months old) and a 19″ Ultrasharp (2 years). No hiccoughs.

    I have a Compaq 15″ monitor that I got a yard sale. The onboard clock says the lamp has been running for 23,000 hours. Works great, no burn in.

    I’ve even got my Sanyo stereo from 1993 wired up to the home PC. All completely working even the 10 disc changer and both full-logic cassette decks.

    Dunno mate, maybe they save the best stuff for Australia!

  • Forgot one

    Nikon SB600 flash gun. Straight out of the box the display panel flashed continuously. Tried new batteries, rechargeables everything, nothing worked. Couldn’t even find the problem online in forums and I bought it from the US so couldn’t return it, no warranty.

    Don’t care, works fine, just takes a few seconds to read the blinking display.

  • Oh and our Dyson DC02 is still going strong too. It better, it cost like $AU700!

  • I hate Kensington. I had two Expert Mouse wireless trackballs. One failed on the X axis. Kensington agreed there was a problem, and shipped me a new one. The 2nd one failed after a year–of the same cause! I just gave up; neither one was fixable–I *do* repair things when they’re feasible.

    Cool and hip gadgeteers are expected to just take out the plastic, rinse and repeat.

  • dtm…no not prototype stuff, regular stuff. You’re lucky or as you say they make ’em tougher for the Outback. :-) David, I don’t think we should have to take the hit time and time again. But then again, I don’t really know what we can do? :-)

  • I know it is an old post – but I have found that I buy by Warrenty now – not by brand. Were possible, the unit must have 2-3 years of warrenty before I even concider the purchase because the way I look at it, the cost of the unit is (Unit Price/Warrent Period).

    This sometimes means I spend a little bit more, but I then know that I have legal support to get the unit fixed, which they must do so within a certain time period (NZ law).

    My list of stuffed, and waste of buy gadgets is ….extensive…. In fact, I'm playing with a BlueAnt X3 right now which refuses to charge…. after 1.5 years of use!!!! What the …..!!!!

    We have become a society of throw away…. just getting really bad when the things you throw away after a year of use cost you good money!

comments powered by Disqus

Side Advert

Write For Us


Managing Editor:
Nigel Powell

Associate Editor:
Caitlyn Muncy
Associate Editor:
Dan Ferris
Ecological Editor:
Debra Atlas
Technology Editor:
Fritz Effenberger
Asian Editor:
Hu Ping
Reviews Editor:
Kevin Evans

FB Like Box