Reviews posted by

Amazon Echo vs Echo Dot V 2.0 – can your life assistant really be digital? [Review]

P1000693 e1480022578292 Amazon Echo vs Echo Dot V 2.0   can your life assistant really be digital? [Review]

The Amazon Echo and Echo Dot hands free ‘intelligent’ home controllers have been on the market for some time now, but with the new release of the Echo Dot Version 2.0 we thought it was a great excuse to check out some state of the art tech. Especially since Amazon is constantly extending the features of the Echo and the rather clever voice assistant called Alexa. Of course there’s no shortage of rivals – step up Siri, Cortana and Google Now – but we wanted to see how well Amazon did as a digital assistant. The answer is, not bad at all!

So what’s special about the new, much smaller, Echo Dot? Well, for one thing it has the same Alexa voice assistant as it’s bigger cousin, and it also has an internal speaker, and even the ability to connect to your own speaker, via either a 3.5mm jack or Bluetooth wireless. Check out our video below for a quick overview of the features of the Echo and Dot.

To understand what Alexa, and both versions of the Amazon Echo, can do, we have spent the last week living with Alexa to see how she can help us in our day- to-day-lives. The first thing to say is the voice recognition of both devices is really very good. They can also pick up voice commands from well over 5m away, and sometimes both devices answered even though they were 3 rooms apart in the house.

amazonechodot Amazon Echo vs Echo Dot V 2.0   can your life assistant really be digital? [Review]

The Echo Dot’s internal speaker is great for everything day-to-day – listening to the news, weather forecast or football results is all very clear with no distortion even at maximum volume. It’s only when you want to start to listen to music for a while that you find the speaker lacking in oooomph – that’s low and top end frequencies to your audio anoraks. However, pairing up to my Bose Soundlink 3 made the Echo Dot come alive.

amazonecho Amazon Echo vs Echo Dot V 2.0   can your life assistant really be digital? [Review]

You can look up recipes to aid with cooking spag or Ramen, or find out the best restaurants around you, once you realise minced meat isn’t the same stuff as mince pies are stuffed with. Ask Alexa for a plumber and she comes through to help with a leaking toilet, but ask her for a policeman and she wants to order some cosplay from Amazon, so there’s a rather uneven quality in the “intelligence” of this AI voice assistant.

echodot2

The full-sized Echo produces a fantastic audio range, and to my ears is very close to the Bose Soundlink 3, and Alexa is just as helpful on this model as she is on the smaller version. I ended up with the Echo in the kitchen and the Echo Dot in the living room, and this seemed to make the best use of her facilities to let you order items, play music, ask for information and have some childish fun too.

Conclusion
Overall I would reccomend the Amazon Echo to anyone who wants to place the Alexa Assistant in an area which doesn’t have external speakers, or if you just want to locate it where you do listen to music a lot but don’t like speakers and wires everywhere. I would say the Echo Dot V 2.0 would suite anyone on a tighter budget and who already has a great audio setup they can easily link Alexa up with. Horses for courses, as they say!

Price: Amazon Echo: $139.99 / £149.99              Amazon Echo Dot V 2.0: $39.99    /  £49.99

I’m a Technologist with a love of Gadgets, Photography & Travel.

I review & test products from a personal perspective, which will hopefully give you the best information you need about each product before you buy it yourself.

I have worked in the Tech industry for 3 decades and studied Electronics and Engineering.

If you want your product reviewing then get in touch >> john@redferret.net

John Gardner – who has written posts on The Red Ferret Journal.


Comments are closed.

comments powered by Disqus

Chinese (Simplified)EnglishFrenchGermanItalianJapanesePortugueseRussianSpanish

Side Advert

Support The Red Ferret

Sponsors

Chinavasion
DHgate Cheap electronics gadgets
TOBI
Firebox

FB Like Box

Personnel

Managing Editor:
Nigel Powell

Associate Editor:
Dan Ferris
Technology Editor:
Donyae Coles
Ecological Editor:
Debra Atlas
Motoring:
Nick Johnson
Reviews:
Roland E.

Write For Us

Red Ferret Video Reviews